REVIEWS

Discussion in 'Oud Oil' started by bhanny, Sep 9, 2016.

  1. RobertOne

    RobertOne Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Nov 10, 2016
    Messages:
    361
    Likes Received:
    494
    Trophy Points:
    93
    Occupation:
    Stay at home dad / cook / cleaner
    Location:
    Aalsmeer, Netherlands
    Oud Thaqueel 2015.

    Sniffing the vial there is a hint of barn that almost entirely vanished on contact with my skin.

    Initial application is camphorous almost in a EO Tigerwood '95 kind of style but much more rough, raw and unready, however there is no denying it's potency.

    On the edges are rose, violets in cream and a distinct Oudy kick.

    Five minutes in it has spun around and become a more nuanced, sweeter FO Old School Thai still with the rose and violet backdraft.

    <review is being conducted live from 21:05 CET>

    Well, my live review style totally failed with me falling asleep next to a restless girl. Pfffft. I will carry on where I left off yesterday, how annoying that life often gets in the way of Oud appreciation.

    It gradually evolves into a perfume like concoction, hard to pin down specific notes except woody, phenolic-medicinal and camphorous. This does sound unappealing but if one were to imagine a band aid sent from above then this would be it.
     
    Last edited: Feb 13, 2018
    Noor ul arfeen likes this.
  2. GalileoFigaroMagnifico

    GalileoFigaroMagnifico New Member

    Joined:
    Feb 3, 2018
    Messages:
    8
    Likes Received:
    14
    Trophy Points:
    3
    Hello friends. I recently shared this review with another forum, and thought it might be useful/informative to members here who are wondering about Grandawood.

    What is it? Wild Oud sampler from Grandawood.com.au Cost: AU$150 for five 0.1 ml sample vials.
    Service: Excellent: quick shipping, good packaging. Grandawood's website though, is infuriatingly naggy. They send you emails and messages if you put stuff in your cart and then leave. I recommend signing out or clearing cookies to avoid this. The origins of the oils are not always easy to determine, either.

    How did I apply these? 2cm swipe of the sample dipstick onto my clean forearm.

    Wild Dark Merauke
    Origin: Merauke, presumably
    1 minute: medicinal blast of eucalyptus, wintergreen and jungle canopy
    3 minutes: the blast has settled into a medium minty freshness (minty like a mint julep, not toothpaste-minty) with a curious and not unpleasant rubber/disinfectant note, like opening up a fresh Band-Aid.
    10 minutes: Potting soil plus ozone, like the air when it's going to rain soon. Settling down a little.
    40 minutes: Has combined well with my skin scent and is now putting off a flinty, high-pitched mineral/earth note, like clean clay.
    80 minutes: Finally safe for company. A lovely leafy green garden aroma.
    110 minutes: Greenness is getting a little less lovely and a little more threadbare. To be honest, it isn't my favorite type of smell.
    140 minutes: The mentholated opening has returned, with a soft woody backdrop, and continues this way until it fades out completely.

    Scasa Saat
    Origin: Cambodia
    1 minute: Rubber, leather, and bacon. Yes, bacon. There's a powerful smoke hit combined with an unmistakable meaty aspect. Quite intriguing but not really presentable yet.
    5 minutes: Still leathery/smoky but the meat has receded (been eaten?)
    15 minutes: Barnyard qualities begin to emerge. Manure, hay and grass combine with the pre-existing leather and wood to make a truly pastoral scent. Cat is suddenly very interested in my arm.
    50 minutes: A most delightful and unexpected sweetness is peeking out. I can't tell if it's honey, maple, molasses or what, but it's lightening and broadening the entire landscape.
    75 minutes: It finally hits me what the sweetness is. About 10 years ago I had the good fortune to smell some fearsomely expensive narcissus absolute, and *this is that scent*: pillowy-soft sweet clean strawlike floral. It's the perfect complement to the barniness. Cat has been locked out of my room because she keeps trying to lick me. Still wouldn't go out in public with this on.
    100 minutes: Whoa, who's started smoking vanilla Cavendish pipe tobacco in my house? THIS is the scent I want to wear in public. Still not 100% barn-free but definitely more presentable.
    150 minutes: Has softened into a smooth dry benzoin-heavy amber. I confess to a weakness for extravagant perfumery ambers like Parfum d'Empire's Ambre Russe and Lutens' Ambre Sultan. This is not that, but rather a softer, more solemn amber. Not completely stripped of the sweet tobaccoey goodness but any mainstream perfume house would be thrilled to package this aroma as their latest amber scent.
    170 minutes: Fade out on soft woody powder.

    The Scent of Enlightenment II: Crimson Flower

    Origin: unknown
    1 minute: LEATHERLEATHERLEATHER with some additional twists of cured and tanned animal hides. ;)
    15 minutes: A strong pine/evergreen note emerges, resinous and tarry but quite pleasant. Reminds me of a piñon salve I got in New Mexico... comfortingly incensey.
    45 minutes: GRAPES. WTF. Bunches and bunches of succulent sweet purple grapes. Not a winey grape scent either. I have a sudden craving for a PB&J.
    75 minutes: Fruitiness has receded to reveal a softly oudy leather/wood note, glazed with a layer of beeswax.
    110 minutes: Well hello there, lapsang souchong tea.
    140 minutes: Woodsy tea until fade out.

    The Forbidden Scent
    Origin: Brunei
    1 minute: Buckets of barnyard, heavy on the hay and manure.
    15 minutes: Manure is receding but this is still uncomfortably high-pitched and immobile.
    45 minutes: Like I said, immobile. Has not changed since last sniff. This could be any commercial Oud Du Jour.
    80 minutes: Holy smoke! Literally, holy smoke. Astoundingly, after nearly an hour and a half, this stagnant and previously unimpressive oud is pouring forth billows of luscious churchy incense smoke. I cannot say if this replicates actual burning agarwood, having never had the pleasure, but WOW is that an impressive effect. It may disturb those around you, it's that realistic.
    120 minutes: Still smokin'. I imagine I can actually see the smoke but realize that is not in fact possible.
    140 minutes: The smoke illusion continues and I feel as though I can actually smell ash from the imaginary incense. Vetiver and grassy notes appear and remain until fade-out.

    Kalimantan
    Origin: Borneo
    1 minute: Sandalwood dust. Smells like an old sandalwood fan my mother had. Smooth, cerealy, very pleasant.
    10 minutes: Still sandalwood, but the tangy yogurty note of great sandalwood is very faint.
    30 minutes: Has not developed significantly, or if I'm to be honest, even moderately. I wonder if this is made with less-infected agarwood? None of the fermentation or animalic notes I've come to associate with the other ouds in this sampler. Still pleasant, but I can't think of a reason to pay big bucks for this over my vintage Caswell-Massey sandalwood EDC or any other good sandalwood.
    60 minutes: Yep, sandalwood. Actually this is bizarrely impressive in its monotonous linear longevity. It's kind of boring on its own but if I were blending a natural perfume and had unlimited funds, I might use this to add a consistent sandalwood tone to my scent.
    90 minutes: I take back what I said at 60 minutes. This is not kind of boring, this is extremely boring. It's nice but absolutely not worth the money and I'm wondering if it's even real, so unchanging it is.

    Which ones would I personally consider FBW? Scasa Saat definitely, Crimson Flower possibly.

    That's all folks, hope this was useful. If the community would like I will also review the Cultivated sampler.
     
  3. kesiro

    kesiro Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Oct 4, 2016
    Messages:
    1,184
    Likes Received:
    1,991
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Location:
    California
    Awesome post and a very hearty welcome! I have tried most of the ones you mentioned and actually purchased some in small quantities. The scasa saat is a good oil for sure. For as 'boring' as the Kalimantan is, and I agree with you, it is quite pleasant and has absolutely zero off putting notes. Making is better to me then some oils which may be more complex or exciting but on drydown start acting weird.
    I think I got 1gm of it. As of the Scasa Saat. As I have some of the best Filaria oils, the Granda Merauke was not my bag. I did buy a full bottle of the Brunei. I just really like Brunei oud oils and I thought it is pretty good actually. Does have a lot of smoke and it does have more balls then nuance, but again, nothing off putting. I was overall happy with the Grandawood stuff. Sorry to say it is not at the level of Ensar's of Taha's stuff, but in reality, what is?
     
  4. GalileoFigaroMagnifico

    GalileoFigaroMagnifico New Member

    Joined:
    Feb 3, 2018
    Messages:
    8
    Likes Received:
    14
    Trophy Points:
    3
    Oh, I agree completely. I was just taken aback at how linear it was. It smells very lovely nevertheless.
    You ain't kidding. I just got my first Ensar Oud parcel last week and it's probably ruined me for anything else. I'm giddy in love with these oils. I have yet to have the honour of trying Taha's works.
    Thanks, nice to be here. :)
     
    RobertOne and Ensar Oud like this.
  5. kesiro

    kesiro Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Oct 4, 2016
    Messages:
    1,184
    Likes Received:
    1,991
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Location:
    California
    Well you can’t tease us like that! Spill the beans!! What did you get??:D
     
  6. GalileoFigaroMagnifico

    GalileoFigaroMagnifico New Member

    Joined:
    Feb 3, 2018
    Messages:
    8
    Likes Received:
    14
    Trophy Points:
    3
    Full-size Oud Yusuf and sample of Borneo Zen perfume. Planning another order within days, possibly hours.
     
  7. RobertOne

    RobertOne Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Nov 10, 2016
    Messages:
    361
    Likes Received:
    494
    Trophy Points:
    93
    Occupation:
    Stay at home dad / cook / cleaner
    Location:
    Aalsmeer, Netherlands
    I just now spied your impressive posts, you are certainly welcome to these here parts despite the fact that you are just a poor boy from a poor family. Hopefully Oud will refine you somewhat.

    Also, try the sampler from EO, your mind will never be the same after applying one every day.
     
  8. GalileoFigaroMagnifico

    GalileoFigaroMagnifico New Member

    Joined:
    Feb 3, 2018
    Messages:
    8
    Likes Received:
    14
    Trophy Points:
    3
    It's in my cart, awaiting funds.
    ;):p
     
    Rasoul S likes this.
  9. Rasoul S

    Rasoul S Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Sep 12, 2017
    Messages:
    1,174
    Likes Received:
    2,238
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Gender:
    Male
    quick impressions of two new ensar oud oils:

    people's sultan:
    ok. easy there ensar and team. you didnt have to go all the way. few started challenging you and your prices and then you do this? holly crap man. if one thinks JSL or green papua hit above their weight, this one, people's sultan is the strongest quality price ratio oil i have seen to date. period. game over. nothing comes close. i mean kanzen or harita from taha are to be mentioned but neither are below $200 even in 3gram size.

    i wont get too much into the scent but here it goes. product description and other's notes already shared on this are bang on. I didn't expect as much vertical complexity but 30 min in and the oil shape shifted to show more papuan green and new guinea gyrinops. even hints of abdus selam incense-y notes are seen. after it settles on the skin, the scent is quite similar to medium to medium+ scent of new guinea signature incense grade chips on an electric heater. i also expected to get an oil with more similarities than differences to both yusuf and JSL, but this couldn't be further from it and i love it for that. the bitterness running thru it is just lovely and something i have only ever seen in much higher priced and higher pedigree oils. is almost aceh/sumatra like bitterness.

    this oil will surely make critics swallow their words and be humbled. i don't suspect this is financially feasible and ensar and team like did this as a marketing tool and a PR message. so jump on it and take advantage everyone. now i challenge @Ensar and @Kruger and team to make an oil with profile of guallam or nha trang or malinau oil as the next sultan.:D

    khmer xtreme:
    objectively speaking yes it is a cross between cambodi (not the fruity or high terpy or the one's that are Vietnamese like) and hindi but due to my aversion to hindi i cant get passed those fermented fruit, leather, tobacco, cacao mass notes. is subtle, is integrated (mostly) and is delicate, but just not for me. for those seeking an oil with assam 05 level of subtlety, this is almost it. certainly more refined than the assam organic in the barn and fermented funk notes. i cant speak to the price or availability since i received this sample as a kind gift.

    my 2 cents.
     
  10. Rasoul S

    Rasoul S Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Sep 12, 2017
    Messages:
    1,174
    Likes Received:
    2,238
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Gender:
    Male
    @GalileoFigaroMagnifico
    looking eagerly forward to read your impressions. you are in for a treat.
     
  11. PEARL

    PEARL Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Mar 4, 2012
    Messages:
    285
    Likes Received:
    741
    Trophy Points:
    93
    Occupation:
    1
    Location:
    Quogue, NY
    Ensar Oud~Suriranka Senkoh

    All I have is my nose. We’ve talked about resin and whether it can be expressed through distillation or only by extraction. Dear @Ensar made the valid statement that it has only been imagined by such things as heating wood and relating that scent to oils. He went further to pose the question, “how can we know what “resinous” smells like if we’ve never encountered raw resin?” I can only state some observations I’ve made with my nose.

    GCMS is capable of comparing a test sample against known chemical/compound markings stored in its database; it then qualifies/quantifies found like chemicals and compounds in the test sample. Our olfactory system does a similar task; we can smell Chamkeila and say it has tobacco LIKE notes, only when we have the scent of various tobaccos stored in our scent memory. They both work by comparison.

    Resin can be expressed through extraction. I only have experience with two agarwood extracts, IO’s Sinensis and Kyarazen’s KZ85. Those two products have more in common with each other than they do with the majority of agarwood oils with a few exceptions, those being oils like Chamkeila and Lalitya to a degree and the Senkoh oils to a greater extent. They both share a texturally sensational incensey core scent, both are thicker than most oils, similar quality in their viscosity and both long lasting but the scent stays close to the skin. The prominent trait that separates them from most agarwood oils though, is the scent texture and incense core scent.

    Suriranka Senkoh opens with the same incense core scent as the extracts. The scent has a textural quality to my nose in much the same way as thick, pebble grained Connolly Hides in a vintage Aston Martin has to my fingertips. It’s a dense, almost fibrous, pulpy scent texture like the non-smoky, cool, condensed first whispers of a gently heated chip. The incense core fragrance lasts throughout the evolution of the oil. As it warms on the skin, the notes many love in Sri Lankan oils emerge; except the Ceylon notes here are cyan hued. The notes are not bright and diffusive like many Sri oils, rather they are heavy, somewhat muted and calming. The progression of the oil has the stillness of a hummingbird in flight as it hovers to use its long bill to coax nectar from a flower. While not a shape shifter or varied note bomb, the complexity is in the overall presentation. The oil has medium, encapsulated bubble projection and above average longevity.

    I have no idea what distillation process was used to express such a scent. I also have no idea if resin is responsible for the scent texture of the extracts and the Senkoh series oils. I do know though, that they are unique and the comparison is undeniable.

    If oils like Oud Nuh, Assam Kinam and Kinam Rouge were to wear oud oils, they’d likely wear oils from the Senkoh Series. Extraordinary oils.
     
  12. kooolaid79

    kooolaid79 Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Oct 11, 2016
    Messages:
    828
    Likes Received:
    1,329
    Trophy Points:
    93
    Gender:
    Male
    Occupation:
    Teacher
    Location:
    Pomona, California
    Thank you for your beautiful review @PEARL. It’s always a delight to read your posts. Your understanding of this beautiful art of nature is acquired by a very few.
    Continue to bless us with your insight, as it brings out joy and a different perspective each time.
     
  13. kesiro

    kesiro Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Oct 4, 2016
    Messages:
    1,184
    Likes Received:
    1,991
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Location:
    California
    @PEARL your posts are as enjoyable as the oils you review. What a wonderful expression. The part about the vintage Aston Martin conjures up quite a few emotions as an Oscar India V8 Vantage coupe has been my dream car since I was in high school. Alas, a dream it shall remain.
     
    Noor ul arfeen, Rasoul S and saint458 like this.
  14. GalileoFigaroMagnifico

    GalileoFigaroMagnifico New Member

    Joined:
    Feb 3, 2018
    Messages:
    8
    Likes Received:
    14
    Trophy Points:
    3
    I meant to buy it, seriously, but I accidentally went on an attar shopping spree instead. Next paycheck.
     
    Rasoul S likes this.
  15. GalileoFigaroMagnifico

    GalileoFigaroMagnifico New Member

    Joined:
    Feb 3, 2018
    Messages:
    8
    Likes Received:
    14
    Trophy Points:
    3
    What is it? Grandawood Cultivated Oud Sampler, AU$50 for five 0.1ml sample vials. See my previous review of the Wild Sampler for information about Grandawood's website and service, all of which still apply.

    The Middle Easterner
    Origin: "the border of Thai and Laos"
    1 minute: Instant barnyard but it's (gasp) a good barnyard, heavy on the wood and lighter on the manure.
    5 minutes: Complexity is increasing but so is the smoothness, with a slightly sweet cocoa note that has my mouth watering.
    20 minutes: Animalic notes (I recognize them as animalic, but I'm not sure whether they are civet or castoreum or what) are making this oud a little sweaty, and not in a bad way. This is not outdoor-friendly yet, but for different reasons: it smells like hot flushed skin. Human? Bovine? Porcine? Equine? Maybe a bit of each.
    40 minutes: Still major sexytime aroma. If you wear conventional eaux de parfum or toilette, an infinitesimal dab of TME underneath would boost the va-va-voom factor quite a bit, I reckon.
    80 minutes: The afterglow: light fruity chypre notes. Patchouli, moss, and a fruit I can't quite identify. Finally presentable Lovers of chypre and vetiver scents are going gaga right now.
    110 minutes: Still detectable and delectable. Feels (can I say this about an oil called "The Middle Easterner"?) very old-school French :D in a Mitsouko/Dioressence sort of way. Remains that way until fade-out.

    Super Smooth Thai Floral
    Origin: Thailand, I guess
    1 minute: Glorious tuberose and jasmine. WOW this is a floral topnote mainstream perfumes can only dream of.
    5 minutes: Honey sweetness and a curious salinity. It's kettle corn, but in oud oil form!
    25 minutes: That dried up quickly: both the swoonworthy flowers and the salty honey are suddenly replaced by a bone-dry camphor/eucalyptus/liniment note.
    40 minutes: The wood is peeking out but the camphor still dominates. It's really nice, though. It's the liniment of the gods. If Hercules had been laboring a bit too hard and hurt himself, this is what he'd rub on his sore shoulder.
    80 minutes: Some of the florals have come back to join the camphoraceous party. Just like it says on the vial, this is super super smooth. The camphor "lifts" the florals so it feels almost like it's floating above my skin.
    100 minutes: Soft clean skin scent until fade out.

    Evergreen Superior
    Origin: Vietnam
    1 minute: Dirty leather and pine tree with chargrilled meat accents. I think Santa brought me a medium-rare porterhouse and left it under the Christmas tree.
    5 minutes: The Christmas tree not only has a steak under it, but a cow and some cow dung as well. The main accord has taken on a dusty, antique feel, which is an interesting effect.
    20 minutes: Dusty barnyard has become a little less dusty and has acquired a powdery floral tinge. Heliotrope, maybe? Not enough to make it presentable, although it is an interesting effect
    50 minutes: Tea tree antiseptic joins the heliotrope, which is an interesting effect.
    80 minutes: Am contemplating the tea tree/woody dry down and am considering my final verdict. It's thumbs leaning down because I didn't find it a particularly pleasing oud. Then I re-read my review above. Every sniff of this oud surprised me with something interesting. It really was an olfactory journey to parts unknown. So, thumbs up out of respect for an oud that, odd as it seems to say, feels very smart.

    The Misty Forest
    Origin: unknown
    1 minute: Mint, tree leaves, and--weirdly, iris. Iridescent, faintly sweet, and thoroughly surprising. If you like iris notes in perfumery, you will love this. I do not like iris notes in perfumery, and therefore I do not love this.
    5 minutes: The pale iridescence of the opening notes has had its purple turned way up: there's violet, heliotrope and sharp lavender. I can't honestly say I like this yet, but it sure is interesting.
    20 minutes: And now we have green tea joining the party. I haven't yet mentioned it but this was publicly wearable from the moment of application and is even more so now. Complex and fascinating.
    50 minutes: Still tea but with more depth as the woody notes come out. I'm really digging this now.
    70 minutes: The mint is back, and now we have a dead ringer for Adore's Moroccan Mint green tea, served just the way I like it--with honey. I should add that leafy, grassy green scents aren't really my bag, and this isn't that except at the very beginning. I'd gladly wear this as an everyday scent: it's both refreshing and calming and remains that way until fade out.

    Floral Superior
    Origin: unknown
    1 minute: Black pine pitch and road tar.
    5 minutes: Whoa nelly, that's some serious barnyard. Plenty of manure along with hay and moldy wood.
    20 minutes: I feel sorry for all the Grandawood customers who saw "floral" in this oil's name and bought it expecting something like Fracas. The manure note is projecting more and more. Needless to say, this is not outdoor-friendly in the least.
    30 minutes: At this point I'd like to define some terms I've seen used in other, more learned reviews. Some may find them interchangeable, and by all means feel free to disagree. but I'd like to clarify the difference as I see it.
    Barnyard: There's a barn, and straw, and animals plus their collected excreta, fur, leather, and wood. Maybe some grass and grains too.
    Fecal: Someone just took a sh*t on the rug.
    Here we have fecal. Oh boy, do we ever.
    40 minutes: There's some leather intermittently peeking through but this is still extremely fecal and terribly rude. Only my solemn duty as a reviewer is keeping me from washing this off. Be grateful.
    55 minutes: I didn't wash, but I did vigorously rub the spot on my arm with a paper towel. The poop is receding a little to reveal a more conventionally oudy wood scent. There's still plenty of poop though. Plenty. Sigh.
    75 minutes: Even though it's 34 degrees out and the air conditioner is running, I have just put on a long-sleeved shirt to cover up the stench. If that doesn't work (this is pungent, if you hadn't guessed) I might spray some Musc Koublai Khan on top to lighten the mood.:eek:
    90 minutes: I think this oud has said just about all it has to say. I've smelt the ways "barnyardy" oud" can still be complex and interesting (see The Middle Easterner, above, or The Forbidden Scent from Grandawood's Wild Sampler, reviewed earlier) but the entire olfactory drama of Floral Superior is really a trial to tolerate. Like Voltaire's Holy Roman Empire, Floral Superior is neither floral nor superior.

    Which would I personally consider full-bottle worthy?The Misty Forest for sure. Super Smooth Thai Floral but mostly for that heavenly tropical-flower opening. The Middle Easterner in theory but maybe not in practice. Evergreen Superior is admirable but not really likeable, if that makes sense.

    Thanks for reading.
     
    Last edited: Feb 18, 2018
    Noor ul arfeen and 5MeO like this.
  16. PEARL

    PEARL Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Mar 4, 2012
    Messages:
    285
    Likes Received:
    741
    Trophy Points:
    93
    Occupation:
    1
    Location:
    Quogue, NY
    @GalileoFigaroMagnifico thanks for the in-depth reviews. I tried one of Grandawood’s oils by way of @kesiro, not sure if farmed or wild but was a decent oil.
    I’m a car nut in general, old and new. I became infatuated with the Aston Martins from watching old James Bond movies; same way I first feel in love with the Walther PPK and Rolex Submariner.
     
    Noor ul arfeen, saint458 and Rasoul S like this.
  17. saint458

    saint458 Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jan 23, 2017
    Messages:
    195
    Likes Received:
    302
    Trophy Points:
    63
    Gender:
    Male
    wOw just WoW ! ... I know exactly what you mean. I use SS very sparingly & always have this feeling.
     
    Rasoul S likes this.
  18. ~A Coburn

    ~A Coburn Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Nov 22, 2017
    Messages:
    188
    Likes Received:
    452
    Trophy Points:
    63
    Gender:
    Male
    Occupation:
    Service
    Location:
    Amman, Jordan
    Hey there, a few people have asked for comparison between Jing Shen Lu and Taigo Senkoh, so I thought a little blurb would be helpful:

    Of the two JSL is louder from the get go, it's a thicker profile with a darker overall tone. Jing Shen Lu is a marinade of fermented dark twiggy spices. Think; anise, fennel, allspice, bay leaves... etc with an herbaceous undertone and a high pitched eucalyptus profile which may be perceived as 'menthol.'

    Taigo Senkoh is cayenne pepper and bright orange cantaloupe, it's a higher pitch, brighter than Jing Shen Lu by quite a few hues. It's a wispy ethereal orange where Jing Shen Lu is a hue of dark brown tinged with yellow. Both have the oscillation of wild wood, the 'it's alive' kind of feel.

    Taigo Senkoh is Spring where Jing Shen Lu is Autumn...
     
    Noor ul arfeen, evogel and Bryan-I like this.
  19. Rasoul S

    Rasoul S Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Sep 12, 2017
    Messages:
    1,174
    Likes Received:
    2,238
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Gender:
    Male
    Multi first wear impressions of new ensar oud releases

    Zazen
    As it has been described by ensar oud. Bitter. Kinamic. A unique kyen note. Cambodi/Vietnamese vibe. Addictive buzzing and awesome. Strong qpr. Recommended. It is in my eyes a poor mans kinam oil. Bravo team ensar for pricing this oil correctly and for being able to churn out such insanely high quality for the price and for the base material.

    Nirvata muana
    I was reallly looking forward to this and I got what I asked for and then some BUT also something different than expected and something I am averesed to. Anyways let’s describe what is, rather than what I thought: Comforting. Calming. Sweet. Rooibos vanilla tea. Very light chai latte. More cream. Touch of coumarin and that unique note that I guess is muana. This special delicious and awesome note gladly takes center stage an hour after wear. What I didn’t expect and was not what I was hoping is a subtle trat nose. This oil opens as if oud yusuf after 10 plus years of aging was blended with something hindi. I know trat notes are a love or hate for many as such buyers be aware. As mentioned the Thai side quiets down fairly quickly in an hour or so and one is left with beautiful roiboos tea vanilla cream and this note that I am happy has a name: muana. Lovely.

    Mustafa 7
    Ultra complex. Vertically and horizontally. Each time I would approach the swiped area a different facet jumped out. It is chinese. It is Indian. It is barny. It is medicInal. It is both. Yet not on every whiff. There is a unique lotus flower note. The wood here smells long soaked and slightly fermented to my nose. Leather is there so is fruit laced tobacco. Touch sour fruit. Powerful beast but so layered and nuanced. This is evidently a super oil. It is not for me but classic hindi fans and general chienese oil lovers will absolutely love this. This oil demands your respect.

    Teaser: I got a mystery oil as a kind gesture sample and AYU fans and those who missed out on it, will be thrilled. I don’t know the name origin price or anything other than an oil that to my nose is malay and ayu’s grand father. I see Logan vs Wolverine here. An aged, powerful, top but also bottom heavy malay oil chuck full of cola notes and all those delicious malay qualities that are somewhat similar to walla yet distinct. Mind you this oil is not for me and neither was ayu. But if someone wanted to see what ayu is like I think this oil will scratch that itch and likely more. It is not as ethereal and as ultra top note diffisuive as ayu but not far behind either. It does for sure have a longer finish and deeper base. There is even a suggestion of purple kinam here. Maybe like a 10% similarity.

    Final closing remark: ensar has been at times criticized by some folks over his write up of his oils but I don’t get the criticism. Not once have I felt deceived. Not once the oil was something different than what was described. And not once was the oil lesser than the write up. Sure the language maybe flowery but that itself is an art and I very much appreciate reading the descriptions and back story. It adds to the enjoyment for me. I don’t see it as hyperbole. Nope. Pls continue the honest path ensar team and stick to the integrity of your work. The oils speak louder than anything else.

    Now leave me alone with my muana. If green Papua is universally loved then this oil will be universally adored. At least after the Thai trat like note blows off. I am hoping there will be more muana oils and ones that put the microscope on that note and accentuate it. Yummmmm
     
  20. Philip

    Philip Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Feb 5, 2017
    Messages:
    243
    Likes Received:
    491
    Trophy Points:
    93
    Thank you Rasoul for these reviews. I look forward to sampling these new releases soon.
    Also, I fell off my chair when you said aged, powerful and heavy Malay :eek::eek::eek:
    Gonna need that asap.
     
    Noor ul arfeen and Rasoul S like this.

Share This Page