I love it, masstika; that we oud fanatics can have differing takes on given ouds... but I think we're not far-off from each-other on our assessments of Mostafa and Khidr.
I'm in 100% agreement that Mostafa carries an air of unapologetic certainty about it. To me; its sheer intensity (which I love) is what gives it that vibe. There's very little that's subtle or quiet about its profile. It's just that its fruity component harkens to the characteristic profile of ouds from other regions, and in my own goofy little (but personal) way of declaring what "classic Indian" means to me; That type, and amount, of fruit doesn't feel "classic", for an Indian, to me.
So, I guess, to my nose, I guess I'd say that Mostafa is unapologetic about carrying non-classically Indian components within its profile. ;-)
That said, if I was forced to choose one "Desert Island Oud", not only between Mostafa and Khidr, but between all ouds that I've tried; Mostafa would be my pick, without hesitation. In that sense, Mostafa is, for me, an undoubted future classic!
I'm in agreement that Khidr is the big-time sleeper among Ensar's current selection. I think many people would find the intensely 'Hindi' quality a bit much, but for those who love a great, great purely Indian oud; it's hard to imagine a better specimen.
Ah, Highland! I prefer to warm the powder (or crush the sticks into powder and warm it), rather than ignite the sticks, but that's a fantastic Tibetan incense, either way. One of my favorites.